Brand vs. generic cold medication

Brand vs. generic cold medication

Should you judge a cold-relief drug by its cover? Explore your options so you can make an informed decision at the pharmacy.
Updated:
2009-10-01 10:34
Published:
2004-11-10 00:00
By 
Christina Bernardo

Let your symptoms guide you

Coughing, sneezing and congested, you head over to the pharmacy in search of products to ease your suffering. But instead of cold relief, you may find more irritation as you're faced with a variety of confusing and time-consuming choices. Don't grab the first cold-relief product in sight. Instead, take a few minutes to pick the right medication and you could alleviate your aching sooner and save yourself time and money in the future. 

Let your symptoms guide you
How do you narrow your search for the medication that's right for you? "Seek a product that treats the symptoms [you're experiencing]," says Ian Stewart, a pharmacist for Shoppers Drug Mart at Six Points Plaza in Toronto. When you're reading a product's label, consider that there are different ingredients to treat different symptoms -- more ingredients in the product does not necessarily make it a better one. In fact, there are risks in taking a product with a long list of ingredients. "You may be taking a product you don't need, "says Stewart. "You may be taking a product that has side effects that might affect you negatively."

Get to know the labels

Stewart recommends reading the package carefully to understand the product's intention, to be aware of the potential side effects and to identify who should not be using it. He also says consumers should consider their medical condition or other medication intake and know which ingredients to avoid because of these factors. For example, "People who have high blood pressure shouldn't take certain medications like decongestants for a stuffy nose," Stewart says. There is a possibility the medication in a decongestant could aggravate the already high blood pressure. If you're concerned about how you may react to a product, consult with your doctor or a pharmacist.

You should also know the chemical names for a product to avoid unintentional double dosing. For example, brand name products like Neocitran and Tylenol contain acetaminophen, "but it doesn't say Tylenol on the box, it says acetaminophen," says Stewart. If you're taking Tylenol and Neocitran and aren't aware that both products contain acetaminophen, "you're doubling up in medication," says Stewart.

Drowsy and non-drowsy drugs
Another thing to consider before buying cold-relief medication is how it can affect your mood. Antihistamines, which are commonly found in cold medication, can reduce nasal mucus and alleviate itchy and watery eyes but these cold-relief joys may not be suitable if you need to be alert: "A common side effect with most antihistamines is that they make you sleepy," says Dr. Fred Eckel R.Ph., professor at the University of North Carolina School of Pharmacy. "It doesn't affect everybody, but it affects some people."

On the other hand, a decongestant, like pseudoephedrine, can relieve your stuffed up nose and watery or itchy eyes. "Oftentimes with a cold you're congested," Eckel says. "You have a hard time breathing, and so a decongestant will help open up the airways to make breathing easier."

Page 1 of 2

Brand- vs. generic-name products

Brand- vs. generic-name products
According to Eckel, consumers can save up to 25 per cent when they buy store-brand products versus name-brand ones. "The reason that the store brand is less expensive than the advertised product is primarily (because of) the cost of promotion," he says. Store-brand products aren't typically advertised and the savings are passed on to the consumer. 

For over-the-counter store-brand medicine, the quality and effectiveness is often equal to the advertised brand and you will probably find that both contain the same active ingredients. "Shoppers Drug Mart certainly is so confident that their brand [Life Brand] is going to have the same effect as the brand name that they have a full money-back [guarantee]," says Stewart. 
On many store shelves, you'll find the generic brand right next to the advertised brand. By comparing the active ingredients of the two packages, you may find that they are equal in potency. You'll often find a difference in the inactive ingredients like the flavouring -- and the price.

Active Ingredients
Before heading to the pharmacy, check out the following list of active ingredients to treat common cold and flu symptoms:

Pain relief (to relieve aches and fever):
• Acetaminophen
• Ibuprofen
• Naproxen Sodium

Cough (suppressants and expectorants):
• Dextromethorphan/Guaifenesin

Runny nose/itchy and watery eyes (antihistamines):
• Diphenhydramine
• Loratadine

Congestion (decongestants):
• Pseudoephedrine
• Oxymetazoline

Page 2 of 2

_

Comments

Advertisement

Sign up for Insider Access,
Our Free E-Newsletter

Contests, recipes, member-only perks and more! Get Homemakers.com's monthly newsletter.

Newsletter

get your
Download of the Month

Weekly meal budget tracker

Could you cut your grocery bill without sacrificing nutrition, variety and taste? Find out by pricing out how much you're spending on your average dinner meal.

Download now!

how to
Follow Homemakers Online

Contests

more contests

Partners

Advertisement Advertisement

Transcontinental Media contact information

Médias Transcontinental
Street Address
1100 Boulevard René-Lévesque Ouest
Extended Address
24th floor
Locality
Montréal
Region
QC
Country
CA
Postal Code
H3B 4X9
Latitude
45°29' 55" N
Longitude
73°34' 13" W
Work
+1 514 392 9000
Fax
+1 514 392 1489